Should You Drop That Insurance Plan? How to Decide
Published by
Throne of Profit EditorialReviewed by
William Hassell
Founder & Chief Editor, Throne of Profit
Every dentist who takes PPO plans has felt the quiet resentment of a fee schedule that keeps getting worse. A plan you signed years ago now writes off a third of your standard fee, and the reimbursement sits below what the chair actually costs you to run. The instinct is either to grit your teeth and keep it — "those patients keep the schedule full" — or to drop it in frustration after one especially bad EOB. Neither reaction is a decision; a real decision starts by asking whether that specific plan, after its specific write-offs, still contributes margin once your chair is full.
That last phrase matters. A discounted plan can be worth keeping when you have empty chair time to fill, and not worth keeping when it's crowding out full-fee or better-paying work. The question isn't whether you like the plan. It's whether the patients it brings are earning you money or quietly costing you the chair.
IS THIS PLAN WORTH KEEPING?
plan reimbursement
│
├─ above chair cost, chair has gaps → keep — it fills capacity
├─ above chair cost, chair is full → maybe — is it crowding better work?
└─ below chair cost → drop or renegotiate — it loses moneyOwner symptoms
You resent a plan's fee schedule but keep it because "the patients keep us busy."
You've thought about dropping a plan but can't say what it would cost or save you.
Your busiest plans feel like your least profitable, and you're not sure why.
Why this happens
Most practices evaluate insurance participation on gut feel and patient volume, not on margin. A plan that books a lot of chairs feels valuable, and dropping it feels like turning away patients. But volume and profit aren't the same thing. When you never separate a plan's reimbursement from its write-offs, and never compare that net against what the chair costs to operate, you can't tell a plan that fills useful downtime from one that's discounting work you could do at a better rate. The busywork hides the math.
Common mistakes
Judging plans by volume, not margin — the busiest plan can be the least profitable.
Treating every plan the same — participation is a per-plan call, not an all-or-nothing one.
Ignoring chair capacity — a discount is fine on empty time, costly when you're full.
Never running the write-off math — resentment isn't a number you can decide on.
Dropping in anger — reacting to one bad EOB instead of the plan's real contribution.
Business consequences
A practice that never runs this evaluation drifts into a schedule packed with work that barely clears cost, or clears nothing, while believing it's busy and healthy. When the chairs are full of below-cost plans, there's no room left for the work that actually funds the practice — so growth stalls even as the days get longer. The owner who evaluates each plan on its net contribution can drop the ones that lose money, renegotiate the ones on the edge, and keep the ones that genuinely fill capacity. That owner ends up less busy and more profitable, which is exactly the trade most practices are afraid to make.
How experienced operators think about it
They treat network participation as a portfolio of margin decisions, one plan at a time, not a philosophy about "taking insurance." For each plan they ask a simple sequence: what does this plan actually net us per typical visit after write-offs, does that net clear what the chair costs to run, and does the volume it brings fill genuine downtime or crowd out better work? A plan that fills empty chairs above cost is a keeper even at a discount. A plan that pays below cost is losing money on every visit — no amount of volume fixes that, because you can't make it up on quantity. The decision is unemotional: keep, renegotiate, or drop, based on the number.
This is general business information, not dental/clinical or professional advice. Consult a qualified professional for your situation.
Practical actions
List every plan separately with its reimbursement and its write-off against your standard fee — one line per plan.
Estimate your chair cost per hour — roughly what an hour of operatory time costs to run, so you have a floor to compare against.
Net each plan against that floor. Flag any plan whose typical-visit reimbursement falls below what the chair costs.
Check the capacity question. For plans above the floor, ask whether they're filling real gaps or displacing full-fee and better-paying work.
Act per plan: keep the ones that fill capacity above cost, renegotiate the borderline ones, and drop or wind down the ones that lose money on every visit.
Questions every owner should ask
Which of my plans actually clears the cost of the chair, and which quietly doesn't?
Am I keeping this plan for its margin, or just because it feels busy?
If I dropped my worst plan, would the freed chair time be worth more than it brings in?
Frequently asked questions
Won't dropping a plan cost me the patients and leave chairs empty?
Some patients will leave, and that's the real trade-off — but empty chairs are only a problem if what left was earning you money. If a plan was paying below what the chair costs, the "lost" volume was a loss on every visit, and the freed time is worth more used for full-fee work or genuinely profitable plans. The honest way to decide is to know a plan's net contribution before you drop it, so you're weighing real numbers against real capacity, not fear against habit.
Isn't more patients always better for a practice?
Not when the added patients are seen at a loss. Volume only helps when each visit clears its cost; below that line, more visits mean more work for less money and less room for the work that funds the practice. A full schedule of below-cost plans can be busier and poorer than a lighter schedule of profitable work. The goal isn't the most patients — it's the most margin your chairs can produce.
Related articles
Running a Profitable Dental Practice — the pillar.
How Much Are Insurance Write-Offs Really Costing You — the write-off math behind this decision.
Which Procedures Actually Make You Money — margin by procedure, not just by plan.
Why Jobs Take Longer Than You Quoted — how underpriced time hides in a full schedule.
Where Time Leaks on a Typical Job — finding the chair time you're giving away.
Every business has more decisions than time
Whether you need help solving one problem, evaluating a major opportunity, or making a company-changing decision, Throne of Profit gives you consulting capacity on demand.
Purchase only the consulting capacity you need and use it across Weekly Focus, Strategic Focus, Financial Focus, and ThinkTank engagements.